Carolina Boots Vs Thorogood Boots

Carolina Boots Vs Thorogood Boots

The major difference between Carolina and Thorogood boots is in how they’re made. Carolina boots have heeled soles that make them a great option for walking on ladders, and rough and uneven terrains, while Thorogood boots have wedged soles that are great for walking on flat surfaces. So, the nature of the activity you want to use your boots for should determine your purchase. 

Construction and manufacturing require employees to be on their feet for long periods. To protect your feet, you need a pair of sturdy boots that will allow you to focus on the task without worrying about injury or discomfort.

While both Carolina and Thorogood boots are among the best brands that produce work boots in the USA, they have pros and cons that distinguish them from each other. In this article, I will reveal everything you need to know about the two boot brands.

Carolina Boots Or Thorogood Boots

The Carolina work boots, as well as the Thorogood work boots, are both American-made and have been around for a long time but is the quality of the Carolina work boots better than the Thorogood work boots?

Thorogood and Carolina’s boots are designed to help you stand up to the daily rigors of your job. Carolina boots are the less expensive option for work boots, while Thorogood is expensive but provides you with better features.

Carolina boots are work and outdoor footwear with a rubber sole and leather upper. They are often used for work and outdoor activities like hiking, fishing, hunting, and casual wear. Thorogood boots are work boot with a rubber sole and leather upper.

Now, let us analyze everything needed to separate these boots.

Carolina Boots Vs Thorogood Boots

Carolina Boots Features

  • Made in the USA
  • Genuine full-grain leather upper
  • Rubber sole
  • Goodyear welt construction
  • Dri-Lex soft lining
  • Impact absorption
  • Steel shank
  • EVA insole
  • Waterproof and slip-resistant
  • Protective toe cap
  • Oil resistant
  • Thinsulate insulation

Thorogood Boots Features

  • Made in the USA
  • Full grain leather upper
  • Non-slip rubber sole
  • Fiberglass shank
  • Leather counter
  • 360-degree split storm welt construction
  • Nice layer of cork
  • Removable insole
  • Waterproof lining

Carolina Boot Shape

From moc to steel toe, aluminum toe, carbon composite toe, and composite toe, Carolina boots come in different toe shapes that you can choose from. Caroline boots are available in lace-up and cowboy styles.

The boots are crafted from full-grain leather uppers and durable rubber soles. These boots are comfortable and waterproof with GORE-TEX technology. These boots also have extra room in the toe box to make your toes comfortable.

The sole is Goodyear welted and stitched down at the same time. This means a more durable sole. The insole of the boots is removable and is made from EVA foam which is the standard in the boot industry. The removable insole means you can easily replace the insole with your favorite insole.

The steel shank of the boot is amazing, and the synthetic polyester counter is also great for optimal comfort. The boot heel cup helps hold them in shape.

Thorogood Boots Shape

Thorogood boots are available in moc toe, steel toe, and round toe. These boots are designed for work and leisure. They are crafted from leather upper and durable rubber materials. They come in different colors, sizes, and designs.

Thorogood boots have a synthetic midsole and a leather counter that conform to your feet. They come with a fiberglass shank which is better than a steel shank. The removable insole is designed with EVA foam, which provides comfort.

The leather is sturdy, and the boots are well constructed with a 360-degree split storm welt that is better than the Goodyear welt. With this welt construction, you can easily resole the boot. The leather is supple and has little to no break-in time.

Carolina Boots Fit

The Carolina boot is true to size. Since the boot brand follows the standard sizing convention, you can order the size you normally order for sneakers. The boots are available in whole and half sizes, so you should not have any problem choosing the right size.

Thorogood Boots Fit

Thorogood boots come in half, and whole sizes, and you can choose your size since they are true to size. You can buy your normal sneaker size for Thorogood boots. If you use size 10, buy the same size in Thorogood boots.

Carolina Boots Vs Thorogood Boots

Carolina Boots Pros And Cons

Full grain leather upperCan be expensive for some
Durable rubber soleNo cork
WaterproofSynthetic polyester counter
Oil and slip resistant
Internal mesh guard
Goodyear welted construction
Thinsulate insulation
EVA foam insole
Shock absorption and impact absorption
Heel cup
True to size

Thorogood Pros And Cons

Premium leather upperExpensive 
Durable rubber soleYou cannot buy it on the Thorogood website
Synthetic midsole and insole
360-degree split storm welt
Excellent slip and oil resistant
Fiberglass sank
True to size
Leather counter cover
Little to no break-in period
Double and triple stitching
Removable insole
Standard leather thickness
Durable and stylish

Comparison Chart

Carolina bootsThorogood Boots
FitTrue to sizeTrue to size
Price$60 to $320$59 to $315
UtilityVersatile Versatile
GripExcellent grip and tractionExcellent grip and traction
ShankSteel shankFiberglass shank
LeatherFull grain leatherFull grain leather
SoleRubber Rubber

Price Comparison

Carolina BootsPriceThorogood BootsPrice
Energy Comp Toe Hiker$144.99Thorogood Men’s Crosstrex$129
Sarge Hi Steel Toe$319.99Thorogood American Heritage Steel Toe$264.95
Elm Steel Toe$174.99Thorogood GEN-Flex2$159
Bruno Lo$179.99Thorogood Infinity FD$240
Insulated Popular Comp Toe$204.99Thorogood 1957$279.95

Which Boot Is Easier To Break In

If you buy the Carolina moc toe boot and Thorogood moc toe boot, both boots can be worn straight out of the box. But if you buy the steel toe of the two brands, the Thorogood boot is easier to break in than the Carolina boot.

Which Boot Is Easier To Maintain

Both boots are very easy to maintain. The leather on the two boots’ uppers is genuine, so you can easily care for them. There are several ways to care for your boot, one of which is always to insert shoe trees into the boots when not wearing them. 

Which Boot Is Better For Different Activities

Both Carolina and Thorogood boots offer similar kinds of boot designs, so they are better for different activities, from work to hiking, fishing, hunting, and casual wear. 

Are Carolina Boots Worth The Money?

Yes, Carolina boots are worth the money because they are durable, functional, and comfortable. Carolina boots are one of the most inexpensive ones on the market that compete with the quality of expensive brands.

Are Thorogood Boots Worth The Money

Though Thorogood boots are a bit expensive, they are worth the money considering the price of some other brands of boots that offer the same boot quality that Thorogood boots offer. So, Thorogood boots are worth every penny you pay for them.

Is Carolina Moc Toe Waterproof?

Yes, the Carolina Moc Toe boot is waterproof. The boot comes with an exclusive proprietary waterproof lining system that prevents water from entering the boot while also wicking out moisture so that your feet can remain fresh and dry.


Regarding Carolina boots and Thorogood boots, only a few features separate them. Both boots are comfortable, functional, and built for performance. They are made of almost the same type of leather but have different insoles and counters.

In the end, Thorogood work boots are better than Carolina work boots in several ways, such as the type of insole, shank, and counter. Thorogood is better in all these aspects and even has a cork. However, the call becomes even stronger when you consider the price of these boots. Thorogood is more expensive, and you can only buy the boots from this brand from other websites, not the Thorogood website.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Boots and Style

© 2024 Boots and Style